Aerospace & Defence — Regulatory & Advisory
Aerospace and defence practice concerns the regulatory framework applicable to defence procurement and production, aviation operations, and the movement of controlled goods and technology. Sagar & Sagar Law Offices advises on defence acquisition and offset requirements, industrial licensing and foreign investment conditions applicable to the sector, export control authorisation, and civil aviation and unmanned aircraft regulation, and acts in contractual and administrative disputes involving public sector purchasers. Work in this practice is regulatory, contractual and advisory in nature.
Overview
Aerospace and defence in India is characterised by a public sector purchaser, a licensed manufacturing base, and controlled movement of goods and technology across borders. Each of these carries its own framework. Procurement follows a codified acquisition procedure with defined categories, indigenous content requirements and offset obligations. Manufacture of specified items requires industrial licensing. Export of controlled items requires authorisation under the foreign trade framework. Foreign participation is subject to sectoral investment conditions.
The practice at Sagar & Sagar Law Offices operates across the regulatory and contractual dimensions of this sector. Work includes advice on participation in defence procurement, structuring of joint ventures and technology arrangements with foreign partners, licensing and authorisation applications, compliance with offset and indigenisation requirements, and representation in disputes arising from contracts with public authorities, including challenges to tender decisions and to debarment.
Scope of work
Defence procurement and acquisition
Participation in acquisition by the armed forces and defence establishments.
- Advice on the acquisition procedure applicable to a proposed procurement
- Advice on acquisition categories and on the eligibility conditions attaching to each
- Advice on indigenous content requirements and on their computation
- Review of requests for information and requests for proposal
- Advice on bid eligibility, consortium arrangements and lead bidder responsibilities
- Preparation and review of bid documentation and undertakings
- Advice on integrity pact obligations and on agent and representative restrictions
- Advice on evaluation, negotiation and contract award processes
- Review and negotiation of defence procurement contracts
- Advice on performance obligations, delivery, acceptance and warranty provisions
- Advice on liquidated damages, penalties and risk purchase provisions
Offsets and indigenisation
Obligations arising from and connected to procurement.
- Advice on applicability of offset obligations to a procurement
- Advice on eligible offset avenues and on the discharge of obligations
- Review and negotiation of offset contracts and undertakings
- Advice on offset banking and on transfer of offset credits
- Advice on selection and engagement of Indian offset partners
- Advice on documentation and reporting for discharge of offset obligations
- Advice on consequences of failure to discharge offset obligations
- Advice on indigenisation programmes and on domestic sourcing requirements
Licensing, approvals and foreign investment
Authorisations required to establish and operate in the sector.
- Advice on industrial licensing requirements for manufacture of defence items
- Applications for industrial licences and for amendments to them
- Advice on licensing under arms legislation and the rules made under it
- Advice on foreign direct investment conditions applicable to the defence sector
- Advice on entry route, approval requirements and conditions attaching to foreign investment
- Advice on security clearance requirements and on the process for obtaining them
- Advice on registration and empanelment with defence procurement organisations
- Advice on establishment of manufacturing operations, including approvals and land matters
Export controls and controlled technology
Movement of controlled goods, software and technology.
- Advice on classification of items against the applicable control list
- Applications for export authorisation for controlled items
- Advice on end-use and end-user documentation requirements
- Advice on obligations under legislation prohibiting unlawful activities in relation to weapons of mass destruction and their delivery systems
- Advice on India's participation in multilateral export control arrangements and its consequences
- Advice on re-export, retransfer and intangible technology transfer
- Advice on internal compliance programmes for export control
- Advice on responses to enquiries and investigations concerning controlled exports
- Advice on import authorisation for controlled items
Industrial collaboration and technology arrangements
Arrangements between Indian and foreign participants.
- Structuring of joint ventures in the defence and aerospace sector
- Technology transfer and licensed production agreements
- Advice on ownership and licensing of intellectual property in collaborative programmes
- Teaming, consortium and subcontracting agreements
- Supply chain and vendor agreements, including flow-down of prime contract obligations
- Advice on confidentiality and security requirements in collaborative arrangements
- Advice on maintenance, repair and overhaul arrangements
- Advice on establishment of production and assembly facilities
Civil aviation regulation
Regulatory framework applicable to aviation operations and infrastructure.
- Advice on the framework governing aircraft, aerodromes and air operations
- Advice on approvals, permits and certification requirements applicable to operators
- Advice on obligations relating to aviation security
- Advice on airport concession, tariff determination and economic regulation
- Advice on aircraft acquisition, leasing and financing arrangements
- Advice on registration and deregistration of aircraft and on repossession
- Advice on the framework implementing international conventions relating to interests in aircraft objects
- Advice on maintenance, repair and overhaul operations and their regulatory requirements
- Representation in regulatory proceedings and appeals
Unmanned aircraft and emerging aerospace
Newer areas within the sector's regulatory framework.
- Advice on the regulatory framework applicable to unmanned aircraft systems
- Advice on registration, pilot certification and airspace classification requirements
- Advice on permissions for operations and on operational restrictions
- Advice on manufacture, import and type certification of unmanned aircraft
- Advice on the regulatory framework applicable to space activities and on authorisation requirements
- Advice on participation by private entities in space sector activity
- Advice on data, imagery and remote sensing regulation
Disputes involving public sector purchasers
Contentious work arising from contracts and administrative decisions.
- Challenges to tender conditions, evaluation and award of contract
- Writ proceedings against administrative decisions of procurement authorities
- Challenges to blacklisting, debarment and suspension of business dealings
- Disputes concerning performance, delay and termination of defence contracts
- Claims relating to price variation, change in scope and change in law
- Arbitration under contracts with public sector purchasers
- Disputes concerning encashment of bank guarantees and performance securities
- Advice and representation in enquiries and investigations concerning procurement
Forums and authorities
- Ministry of Defence and its acquisition and production organisations
- Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade, in industrial licensing
- Directorate General of Foreign Trade, in export authorisation
- Directorate General of Civil Aviation
- Bureau of Civil Aviation Security
- Airports Economic Regulatory Authority
- Authority responsible for authorisation of space sector activity
- High Courts, in writ jurisdiction over administrative and procurement decisions
- Arbitral tribunals constituted under public sector contracts
- Commercial Courts and Commercial Divisions
- Supreme Court of India
Who we act for
- Indian manufacturers and suppliers in the defence and aerospace sector
- Foreign original equipment manufacturers participating in Indian procurement
- Joint ventures established for defence production
- Indian offset partners and subcontractors
- Micro, small and medium enterprises in the defence supply chain
- Aviation operators, lessors and service providers
- Maintenance, repair and overhaul operators
- Unmanned aircraft manufacturers and operators
- Entities in the private space sector
- Investors in aerospace and defence businesses
How we approach this work
Regulatory position established before commercial commitment.
Licensing, investment conditions and export authorisation determine whether an arrangement is capable of performance. These are assessed before documentation is settled.
Prime contract obligations traced through the supply chain.
Offset, indigenous content and security obligations imposed on a prime contractor are frequently discharged through subcontractors. Flow-down of those obligations is drafted deliberately rather than by incorporation.
Administrative decisions treated as reviewable.
Tender decisions, debarment and suspension are administrative acts subject to standards of fairness and reasonableness, and are assessed on that basis rather than accepted as final.
Scope confined to regulatory and contractual matters.
The practice concerns licensing, contracting, compliance and dispute resolution. It does not extend to technical, operational or capability matters.
Frequently asked questions
- What governs defence procurement in India?
- Defence acquisition by the Ministry of Defence is conducted under a codified acquisition procedure which sets out categories of acquisition, eligibility conditions, indigenous content requirements, evaluation processes and contracting provisions. Separate provisions apply to revenue procurement. The procedure is revised periodically, and the version applicable to a particular procurement is that specified in the tender documentation.
- What are defence offsets?
- Offsets are obligations imposed on a foreign vendor in specified procurements to undertake or facilitate qualifying activity in India, such as sourcing from Indian entities, investment or transfer of technology, to a value determined as a proportion of the contract. The avenues through which offsets may be discharged, and the documentation required to establish discharge, are prescribed by the applicable policy.
- Is an industrial licence required to manufacture defence items?
- Manufacture of items specified in the applicable notifications requires an industrial licence under the framework governing industrial licensing, and licensing under arms legislation applies to specified categories of arms and ammunition. Whether a licence is required depends on the classification of the item proposed to be manufactured, which is assessed against the notified lists.
- Can foreign companies invest in Indian defence manufacturing?
- Foreign direct investment in the defence sector is permitted subject to sectoral conditions, with investment up to a specified proportion permitted under the automatic route and beyond that requiring government approval, subject to the conditions in force, including those relating to security. The applicable limits and conditions should be verified against the policy in force at the time of the investment.
- What is the SCOMET list?
- The control list applicable to special chemicals, organisms, materials, equipment and technologies specifies items whose export is restricted and requires authorisation under the foreign trade framework. Exporters are required to classify items against the list and, where an item is listed, to obtain authorisation before export, supported by end-use and end-user documentation.
- Can a blacklisting or debarment decision be challenged?
- Decisions suspending or debarring an entity from business dealings are administrative decisions and have been subjected to judicial review on grounds including absence of a show cause notice, denial of hearing, disproportionality of the period imposed and absence of reasons. Challenges are ordinarily brought in writ jurisdiction before a High Court.
- What regulates drone operations in India?
- Operation of unmanned aircraft is governed by rules made under the aviation legislation, which provide for registration of aircraft, certification of remote pilots, classification of airspace into zones, type certification of aircraft, and restrictions on operations. Requirements vary with the category and weight of the aircraft and with the nature of the operation proposed.
- Are private entities permitted to undertake space activities in India?
- Participation by private entities in space sector activity is permitted subject to authorisation by the designated authority and to the conditions applicable to the activity concerned, with policy in this area having been liberalised in recent years including in relation to foreign investment. The framework continues to develop, and the position should be verified against the policy and authorisation requirements in force.
Related practice areas
For enquiries relating to this practice area, please use the details on the Contact page.